Annual Cheesy Sale

Clear all

Sort by:Recommended

Harman's 9+ Year-Aged Cheddar
- $30.00
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 128 of that item available
Harman's 4+ Year-Aged Cheddar
- $20.00
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 371 of that item available
- 8% off
Harman's Vintage 2024*
- 8% off
  $12.75save $1.00
- $11.75
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 4068 of that item available
- 12% off
Cabot Hot Habanero Cheddar Cheese
- 12% off
  $8.50save $1.00
- $7.50
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 7 of that item available
- 17% off
Cheese Knives & Fork Set
- 17% off
  $17.95save $3.00
- $14.95
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 11 of that item available
- 20% off
Westminster Mini Saltine Crackers
- 20% off
  $5.95save $1.20
- $4.75
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 103 of that item available
- 15% off
Castleton Artisanal Crackers
- 15% off
  $8.25save $1.25
- $7.00
Product amount in cart
- 11% off
Maxine's Cheese Balls
- 11% off
  $8.95save $0.95
- $8.00
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 39 of that item available
- 11% off
Cheese Straws with Jalapeno
- 11% off
  $8.95save $1.00
- $7.95
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 4 of that item available
- 20% off
Moxie Mustard
- 20% off
  $12.50save $2.55
- $9.95
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 25 of that item available
- 9% off
Vermont Epicurean Garlic Mustard
- 9% off
  $8.50save $0.75
- $7.75
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 36 of that item available
- 21% off
2025 Gold Maple Syrup
- 21% off
  $29.00save $6.00
- $23.00
Out of stock
- 20% off
SALE: 2025 Pure Maple Syrup
- 20% off
  $10.00save $2.00
- $8.00
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 20 of that item available
- 23% off
SALE: 2025 Maple Syrup - Grade A: Very Dark
- 23% off
  $23.50save $5.50
- $18.00
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 5 of that item available
- 17% off
Sugar Bob's Sriracha
- 17% off
  $15.00save $2.50
- $12.50
Product amount in cart
- 11% off
Lyman’s Pickled Garlic
- 11% off
  $13.50save $1.50
- $12.00
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 14 of that item available
- 25% off
Wild Petite Sardines in Olive Oil
- 25% off
  $7.00save $1.75
- $5.25
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 23 of that item available
- 12% off
Maple Cream Cookies
- 12% off
  $7.95save $0.95
- $7.00
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 24 of that item available
- 18% off
Maple Sugar Coated Nuts
- 18% off
  $9.50save $1.75
- $7.75
Product amount in cart
- 32% off
Old-Fashioned Clove Drops
- 32% off
  $4.75save $1.50
- $3.25
Product amount in cartSorry, we only have 13 of that item available

Store Categories

Refine Your Search

Annual Cheesy Sale

Harman's 9+ Year-Aged Cheddar

Harman's 4+ Year-Aged Cheddar

Harman's Vintage 2024*

Cabot Hot Habanero Cheddar Cheese

Cheese Knives & Fork Set

Westminster Mini Saltine Crackers

Castleton Artisanal Crackers

Maxine's Cheese Balls

Cheese Straws with Jalapeno

Moxie Mustard

Vermont Epicurean Garlic Mustard

2025 Gold Maple Syrup

SALE: 2025 Pure Maple Syrup

SALE: 2025 Maple Syrup - Grade A: Very Dark

Sugar Bob's Sriracha

Lyman’s Pickled Garlic

Wild Petite Sardines in Olive Oil

Maple Cream Cookies

Maple Sugar Coated Nuts

Old-Fashioned Clove Drops

Store Categories

Refine Your Search

Annual Cheesy Sale

Footer navigation